EFT vs ACH: Canadian and US bank payments compared
EFT and ACH are the batch bank-to-bank payment systems of Canada and the United States: EFT moves Canadian dollars through Payments Canada's Automated Clearing Settlement System (ACSS), and ACH moves US dollars through the ACH Network under the Nacha Operating Rules. Both carry direct deposits and pre-authorized debits, but their rules, file formats, settlement timing and return windows differ. TIB Finance, the Canadian sovereign payment processor, runs Canadian EFT and US ACH payments from one platform and one API.
Updated • Registered PSP with the Bank of Canada • PCI DSS • SOC 1 & SOC 2 Type 2
What is the difference between EFT and ACH?
In Canada, EFT (electronic funds transfer) is the everyday name for what Payments Canada calls automated funds transfer (AFT): AFT credits are direct deposits such as payroll, and AFT debits are pre-authorized debits (PAD) such as mortgage payments. They clear through the ACSS, which Payments Canada owns and operates and the Bank of Canada oversees.
In the United States, ACH (Automated Clearing House) is the nationwide network through which banks exchange batches of electronic credits and debits. The Federal Reserve Banks (FedACH) and the Electronic Payments Network (EPN) are its two national operators, and Nacha writes the rules.
Same job, two separate systems: EFT is often called "Canada's ACH". For a primer, read ACH and EFT payments explained.
How do Canadian EFT and US ACH compare?
| Criteria | Canadian EFT | US ACH |
|---|---|---|
| Currency and reach | CAD, between Canadian financial institutions | USD, reaching all US bank and credit union accounts |
| Network and operator | ACSS, operated by Payments Canada, settled at the Bank of Canada | ACH Network, operated by FedACH and EPN |
| Governing body and rules | Payments Canada: Rules F1 and F4 (AFT), Rule H1 (PAD) | Nacha: Nacha Operating Rules |
| File format | Standard 005 (1,464-character records) or ISO 20022 AFT messages | Nacha format, 94-character lines |
| Bank account details | 3-digit institution, 5-digit transit, account number | 9-digit routing number, account number |
| Settlement timing | Previous day's net balances settle each business morning | Four settlements per business day; Same Day ACH within hours |
| Debit dispute window | Personal PAD: 90 calendar days. Business PAD: 10 business days | Most returns: 2 banking days. Unauthorized consumer debit: 60 calendar days |
| Return codes | Three-digit codes, such as 901 (NSF) | R codes, such as R01 (insufficient funds) |
| Typical costs | Set by each bank or processor; no network-wide retail rate | Set by each bank or processor; no network-wide retail rate |
| 2025 volume | 10.6 billion items worth $10 trillion (all payment items through the ACSS) | 35.2 billion payments worth $93 trillion |
| With TIB Finance | EFT, PAD and direct deposit; deposits in T+1 to T+2 | ACH in USD through the same API and webhooks |
Canadian values in CAD, US values in USD. Sources: Payments Canada, retail batch payment system, Nacha, What is ACH and Payments Canada Rule H1.
How long do EFT and ACH payments take?
Canadian EFT settles on a net basis: the previous day's net balances settle through the Bank of Canada every business morning. With TIB Finance, EFT and PAD deposits land in T+1 to T+2.
ACH settles four times a day on business days. Same Day ACH moves credits and debits within hours, up to $1 million per payment, a limit Nacha raises to $10 million on September 17, 2027. Cut-off times vary by bank and processor: see EFT cut-off times.
What happens when an EFT or ACH payment is returned?
Under Payments Canada Rule H1, a payor can claim a personal PAD up to 90 calendar days after the debit, and a business PAD up to 10 business days. Under the Nacha Operating Rules, most ACH returns, insufficient funds included, are due within two banking days, but a consumer can return an unauthorized debit up to the 60th calendar day.
Canadian consumer debits stay open longer, so your PAD agreements must be airtight: see PAD rules in Canada, EFT return codes and NSF and returned payments.
How do cross-border payments work between Canada and the US?
Neither network crosses the border on its own. Under the Nacha Operating Rules, when a payment originates with, transits through or is delivered to a financial institution outside the United States, its US leg must be sent as an International ACH Transaction (IAT), which carries information on every party to the payment and cannot be sent as Same Day ACH. In Canada, US-dollar items clear through Payments Canada's U.S. Bulk Exchange (USBE), which settles through correspondent banks in New York.
The efficient model for a business active in both countries is to use each country's domestic rail: EFT or PAD in Canadian dollars for Canadian counterparties, ACH in US dollars for US counterparties, both from a single TIB Finance API.
What does TIB Finance offer for EFT and ACH?
TIB Finance is a Canadian sovereign payment processor headquartered in Montreal, Quebec, and a payment service provider registered with the Bank of Canada under the Retail Payment Activities Act (RPAA) since September 28, 2026.
Canadian EFT and PAD
EFT debits and credits, PAD and direct deposits by portal, file upload or API, in batches of up to 5,000 operations.
Bank paymentsUS ACH
ACH payments with US bank accounts, in US dollars, through the same API and webhooks as your Canadian payments.
API use casesInstant payments in Canada
When a payment cannot wait for a batch, TIB's proprietary instant payment system and Interac e-Transfer move funds in seconds.
Instant paymentsBuilding a platform for businesses in Canada and the US?
TIB Finance is built for B2B and for multi-tenant payment processing. If your software serves its own business clients, you onboard them, your tenants or sub-merchants, on top of TIB Finance and run their bank payments on both sides of the border under your own offer. TIB Finance is proven and rigorous, and its team works for its clients and its partners. See the partner program or how our team integrates TIB Finance with you.
How do you process EFT and ACH payments with TIB Finance?
Open your account
Complete onboarding online and activate your payment methods.
Test in the sandbox
Get API credentials by email and test EFT, ACH and PAD flows from your own code, free.
Send your payments
Call the REST API or an SDK (.NET, Java, Node.js, PHP, Python, JavaScript) to send EFT one by one or in batches of up to 5,000, and ACH through the same API.
Track and reconcile
Webhooks report each payment's status and the reason for any return (insufficient funds, account error, stop payment), so your books match the bank.
Frequently asked questions about EFT and ACH
What is the difference between EFT and ACH?
EFT is Canada's batch bank payment system and ACH is the US one. EFT clears Canadian dollars through Payments Canada's ACSS, while ACH clears US dollars under the Nacha Operating Rules. TIB Finance processes both from one API.
Can I send an ACH payment to a Canadian bank account?
Not as a domestic ACH entry. A payment entering or leaving the United States through the ACH Network must be sent as an International ACH Transaction (IAT). The simpler route: EFT for Canadian accounts, ACH for US accounts.
How long can a customer dispute a debit?
In Canada, Rule H1 allows a claim on a personal PAD up to 90 calendar days after the debit, and on a business PAD up to 10 business days. In the US, a consumer can return an unauthorized ACH debit up to the 60th calendar day.
What file formats do EFT and ACH use?
EFT files follow Payments Canada Standard 005, with 1,464-character records, or the ISO 20022 AFT message format. ACH files follow the Nacha format, with 94-character lines. With the TIB Finance API or portal, you never build these bank files yourself.
Does TIB Finance process ACH payments in the United States?
Yes. TIB Finance processes payments in Canada (EFT, PAD, Interac and cards) and in the United States (ACH and cards), in CAD and USD from a single integration.
Is TIB Finance regulated in Canada?
Yes. TIB Finance (9372-2544 Québec inc.) is a payment service provider registered with the Bank of Canada under the Retail Payment Activities Act since September 28, 2026. It is PCI DSS compliant and SOC 1 and SOC 2 Type 2 audited.
Which guides go further on bank payments?
Run Canadian EFT and US ACH from one account. Let's talk.
Tell us how you collect and pay on both sides of the border. A real, bilingual team works with you from the first call to go-live, and stays with you after. TIB Finance sends people, and integration is free for eligible businesses. Developers can start in the free sandbox right away.